Posted on: November 2, 2026 Posted by: Lisa Pietsch Comments: 0

The celebrity-and-hype model that drove a decade of agave spirits growth is collapsing under its own weight. Here is what brand owners need to do instead.

Let me be direct about something. The conditions that made celebrity tequila brands an easy business have changed, and they are not coming back. The US market, which absorbed a decade of agave spirits growth like a sponge, has reached a stage of saturation that even the most famous faces on earth cannot paper over. Discretionary spending is tighter, consumers are smarter, and the shelves are full. The question for every brand owner right now is not whether the old model worked. It did, for a while, for some people. The question is what comes next.

The answer, backed by the data and by everything that serious observers of this category have been saying for the past two years, is authenticity. Not the marketing version of authenticity, which is usually a lifestyle photoshoot in Jalisco and a founder’s note about a grandmother’s recipe. Real authenticity. The kind that starts in the field, runs through the production process, and shows up honestly in the glass. The kind that can survive a question from a knowledgeable consumer, a bartender who has tasted everything, or a journalist who actually knows what NMR testing is.

If that sounds like a higher bar, it is. That is precisely the point.

What Collapsed and Why

The numbers tell a clear story. Celebrity tequila volumes grew 40 percent globally in 2022, three times the rate of the overall category, according to IWSR data. Investors poured money in. New brands launched almost weekly. Shelves filled with bottles backed by athletes, musicians, and actors whose relationship with agave spirits ranged from genuine enthusiasm to a licensing arrangement and a photo opportunity.

Then the hangover arrived. By 2024, category revenue growth had slowed to 2.9 percent. Ultra-premium tequila volumes fell 8 percent in the US between January and July of that year, according to IWSR’s US Navigator data. Kendall Jenner’s 818 Tequila slowed hiring and pulled back on marketing, with its CEO publicly acknowledging that consumers had shifted toward more deliberate purchases. The Mexican distillery system, meanwhile, had accumulated an estimated 500 million liters of surplus tequila, the result of boom-era agave plantings all maturing at once. Agave prices crashed from a peak of roughly $1.60 per kilogram to as low as $0.10, devastating the farmers who had planted in anticipation of continued growth.

And then came the lawsuits. Beginning in early 2025, class action suits were filed against Diageo, alleging that Casamigos and Don Julio were adulterated with industrial alcohol despite being labeled 100 percent agave. Similar suits followed against Cincoro Tequila and 818. Costco’s Kirkland Signature Anejo Cristalino was implicated. The cases cited Nuclear Magnetic Resonance laboratory testing as a method for detecting adulteration, and drew heavily on reporting by Mezcalistas and protests by agave farmers in Jalisco who had been raising alarms since late 2024. Diageo has denied the allegations. The cases are ongoing. But the reputational damage to the broader category’s credibility, and particularly to the image of premium and celebrity-backed brands, is already real.

Consumers who were sold prestige are now asking hard questions about what is actually in the bottle. That is a problem that no amount of marketing spend can fix.

The combined effect of slowing demand, agave oversupply, premium fatigue, and a metastasizing authenticity scandal has fundamentally changed the environment for brand owners. It is a problem that only transparency can address.

What the Market Rewards Now

The brands gaining ground in this environment share a set of characteristics that have nothing to do with fame and everything to do with craft. According to Drinks International’s 2025 Brands Report, Tequila Ocho, now owned by Heaven Hill, climbed the bartender preference rankings on the strength of its agave-forward profile, terroir-driven production, and the Estes family’s longstanding relationships in the industry. Tapatio, which makes no pretense of celebrity involvement, saw its house pour designation rise in polled bars. These are not accidents. They are the predictable result of a more educated consumer base and a bar trade that has never had patience for hollow positioning.

The broader data supports this direction. IWSR projects that the premium-and-above segment will account for the vast majority of agave spirits value growth through 2028, but the definition of what earns a premium price has shifted. It is no longer sufficient to charge $80 a bottle because the label looks expensive. The consumer willing to spend that money in 2025 wants to know where the agave was grown, who harvested it, how long it took to mature, what the distillation method was, and whether the finished product contains additives. Brands that can answer those questions confidently, and prove the answers, are the ones holding and building share. Brands that cannot are losing ground.

The additive-free movement, once a niche concern among spirits geeks, has become a mainstream credibility marker. The Additive Free Alliance’s certification program has grown despite ongoing legal pressure from the CRT, and the growth of websites and communities dedicated to cataloging additive use across major brands has put producers on notice that their formulas are no longer trade secrets in practice, whatever the law may say. Brands that voluntarily disclose their production methods, including additive use or the lack thereof, are building the kind of trust that no ad campaign can manufacture.

Six Ways to Build on Substance

What follows is not a prescriptive marketing checklist. It is a set of approaches that brands with genuine production stories can use to make those stories visible and credible to the consumers, buyers, and bartenders who are now doing the work of separating signal from noise.

1. Open the Distillery for Real

Not for curated press trips with carefully staged jimador photo opportunities. Distillery visits that allow consumers, trade buyers, and journalists to see the actual production process, ask questions of the actual distillers, and taste the product at various stages of production are among the most powerful tools available to a brand with a legitimate story to tell. The operative phrase is legitimate story. If your production relies on practices you would prefer visitors not see, this strategy will backfire. If it does not, the transparency dividend is enormous.

Brands running serious visitor programs are finding that the people who come tend to become advocates with a depth of conviction that no sponsored post can replicate. They have been there. They have tasted the cooked agave. They have talked to the master distiller. That experience travels.

2. Let the Long Interview Do the Work

There is a reason that the spirits categories with the deepest consumer loyalty, Scotch whisky and Cognac being the obvious examples, have long traditions of editorial storytelling. Twelve-hundred-word profiles of master distillers, multi-part features on production methods, conversations with agronomists about agave varietals: this is the content that builds durable affinity and category understanding simultaneously.

A long-form interview, done seriously, with a brand founder or production director who genuinely knows what they are talking about is worth more than a year of Instagram content to the consumers who are actually going to become loyal customers. These are not casual drinkers who need to be entertained into a purchase. They are people who want to understand what they are drinking. Give them something to understand.

The format matters. A conversation that gets into the specifics — the agave source, the cooking method, the fermentation vessel, the still type, the water, the reason for every decision that was made — is not a sales pitch. It is education. Consumers who learn from it become advocates. They recommend the bottle at the dinner party. They ask for it by name at the bar. They are the most valuable marketing asset you have, and they are activated by knowledge, not by celebrity.

3. Show the Farming Relationship

The agave adulteration scandal has put the spotlight on agave farmers in a way that no PR campaign could have engineered. The agaveros who protested in Tequila, Jalisco, and whose grievances eventually found their way into US federal courtrooms, are not just a news story. They are a reminder that agave spirits exist because families have been cultivating this plant, often for generations, under conditions that the premium price on the finished bottle rarely reflects fairly.

Brands that have genuine, long-term relationships with agave farmers and can document those relationships transparently are sitting on a story that resonates deeply with the consumer who is now asking hard questions about what is in the bottle and where it comes from. That means naming the farmers, showing the parcels, explaining the varieties, and being honest about the pricing arrangements. It is a story about integrity in the supply chain, and it is one of the most powerful differentiators available in a market where that integrity has been publicly questioned.

4. Pursue Additive-Free Certification and Say So

The Additive Free Alliance certification is not universally recognized and is itself caught up in legal disputes with the CRT, but its significance as a consumer trust signal has grown substantially since the adulteration lawsuits began. Brands that can credibly claim and document that their products contain no additives are in a position to benefit from the reputational damage being sustained by brands that cannot. That means getting the certification where possible, being specific and verifiable in additive-free claims, and making the case in plain language that consumers can understand.

The regulatory landscape around additives in tequila and mezcal is genuinely complicated. A product labeled 100 percent agave can still legally contain small amounts of caramel color, oak extract, glycerin, and sugar syrup under current CRT rules. Many consumers do not know this. Explaining it clearly, and explaining what your brand does differently, is an act of consumer education that simultaneously positions you as honest and builds lasting credibility.

5. Invest in the On-Premise Relationship

IWSR data shows that tequila holds a 23.5 percent volume share in on-premise channels, accounting for 35.6 percent of premium sales. The bar and restaurant trade has been the proving ground for every serious agave spirits brand that has built durable market share, and it remains the place where consumers are educated about the category at the point of consumption. That education is delivered by bartenders, and bartenders are not impressed by celebrity.

What bartenders respond to is quality, consistency, and the ability to talk about a product with genuine knowledge. Brands that invest in serious trade education programs — not just free pours and branded merch but actual depth on production, agave varieties, regional differences, and tasting technique — are building advocates who will recommend the product night after night to exactly the consumers who are most likely to become loyal customers. The Drinks International data on Tapatio and Ocho is a direct readout of this dynamic. Neither brand has a celebrity co-founder. Both have earned the respect of the bar trade through quality and authenticity, and that respect shows up in house pour designations and cocktail menu placements.

6. Be Patient With the Story

This is perhaps the hardest piece of advice to follow in an industry where quarterly sales figures drive decisions and every distributor wants to know what the brand is doing to drive velocity this month. But the brands that have built genuine equity in agave spirits — Fortaleza, Tapatio, El Tesoro, Ocho, Rey Campero, Vago — have done it over years and decades, not quarters. They have told consistent stories about consistent products and let the liquid do the persuading.

The environment in 2025 and beyond is actually more favorable to this kind of brand building than it was five years ago, when the category was flooded with money and noise. The noise is receding. Shelf space that was occupied by brands with no real story is beginning to open up. The consumers who remain most engaged with agave spirits are increasingly the ones who want to learn and who reward honesty with loyalty. That is a better audience than the hype cycle ever produced, and it is an audience that will still be buying from you when the next celebrity launches a spirit in whatever category captures attention next.

The Opportunity in the Wreckage

Markets that correct tend to overcorrect, and the panic visible in some corners of the agave spirits industry right now is probably an overcorrection. The category still outperforms the broader spirits market. International growth in Europe and Asia is real and accelerating. The long-term consumer trend toward premium, craft, and artisanal products has not reversed. What has ended is the period when none of that actually had to be true of a specific brand for the brand to succeed. The rising tide lifted a lot of boats that had no business being in the water. The tide is normalizing, and the boats that were always seaworthy are not in trouble.

Brand owners who have built their products on honest production, genuine agave relationships, and real quality have nothing to fear from a market that is asking harder questions. For them, the recalibration is not a threat. It is an opportunity to be seen clearly, probably for the first time, by consumers who were previously distracted by the spectacle of the boom.

The work is to make sure those consumers can find you, hear your story, understand it, and trust it. That is a job for editorial depth, trade relationships, supply chain transparency, and time. It is not a job for a famous face on a label. That face has done what it was going to do. What comes next is up to the actual makers.